BatchLeads powered by PropStream
Log In
Free Trial

Shelter Island Properties in NY

There are 3,602 Shelter Island properties in NY. Select any of the properties below to learn more.
Properties > All Real Estate Properties > Shelter Island, NY

All Filters

High Equity
Absentee Owner
In State Absentee Owner
Free and Clear
Unknown Equity
Cash Buyer
Corporate Owned
Tired Landlord
Out of State Owner
Out of State Absentee Owner
Owner Occupied
Mailing Address Vacant
Listed Below Market Price
Inherited
Low Equity
On Market
Active Listing
Recently Sold
Canceled Listing
Expired Listing
Pending Listing
Vacant
Same Property and Mailing Address
Notice of Default
Preforeclosure
Tax Default
Has HOA Fees
Active Auction
Notice of Sale
Building Square Feet
–
Bedroom Count
–
Bathroom Count
–

Access even more Property Characteristics including: Basement Type, Building Class, Condition, Drivway, Exterior, Flooring, Garage, Roofing, Sewer, Year Built, and more..

View More Details

Gain access to MLS filters

View More Details

Gain access to Foreclosure/Auction

View More Details

Gain access to Ownership info

View More Details

Gain access to Valuation & Equity

View More Details

Gain access to Mortgage Info

View More Details

Gain access to Cash Buyers

View More Details

Gain access to Demographics

View More Details
Update Filters
Update
Clear All

3,602 

properties available

Sign up to view all listings
61 On-Market
3,541 Off-Market

Estimated Total Value
$2,174,701

Year Built: 2017
6 5 6,688 SqFt
Great Circle Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$2,809,529

Year Built: 1954
3 2 1,674 SqFt
Bay Shore Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$2,950,000

Year Built: 1890
4 2 2,016 SqFt
Grand Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
Not available

Year Built: 1973
5 4 4,389 SqFt
Gardiners Bay Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$1,741,057

Year Built: 1991
3 2 3,038 SqFt
Fox Hollow Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
Not available

Year Built: 2000
3 2 2,962 SqFt
C W Neck Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$1,695,000

Year Built: 1960
3 2 1,702 SqFt
S Menantic Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$4,995,000

Year Built: 1998
4 4 3,676 SqFt
Cove Way Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
Not available

Year Built: 1962
3 2 2,851 SqFt
Hagar Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
Not available

Year Built:
0 0 SqFt
Dickerson Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$1,778,879

Year Built: 1990
3 3 3,607 SqFt
Crescent Way Shelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Total Value
$2,964,275

Year Built: 1995
4 2 3,061 SqFt
Ram Island Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Try risk free for 7 days

All-inclusive phone numbers and emails on every plan

Growth

$
119
/mo
Start Free Trial

For the solopreneur growing your business.

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
10k monthly leads
20k monthly exports
BatchRankAI (limited)
3 total users
Nationwide listing & property data
140+ customizable lead filters
Built-in marketing & driving for dollars

RECOMMENDED

Professional

$
349
/mo
Start Free Trial

Take full advantage of the product suite.

Everything in Growth, plus:

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
35k monthly leads
70k monthly exports
BatchRankAI
Click-to-dial
8 total users
Discounted direct mail

Scale

$
749
/mo
Start Free Trial

You’re ready to put some jet fuel in the tank.

Everything in Professional, plus:

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
75k monthly leads
150k monthly exports
26 total users
Maximum discounts on in-app purchases

Other Distress factors in Shelter Island Properties in NY

Many of the 3,602 Shelter Island Properties in NY contain other distress factors.

3,538+

High Equity

3,192+

Absentee Owner

2,673+

In State Absentee Owner

2,665+

Free and Clear

2,418+

Unknown Equity

1,310+

Cash Buyer

1,247+

Corporate Owned

617+

Tired Landlord

Searches Related to Shelter Island Properties in NY

Join more than 10,000 real estate pros

Start Free Trial

Featured

Resources to help you grow your business

How to find expired listings
How to Find Expired Listings

In the current housing market, finding inventory can be a challenge. For real estate investors, that means

IS WHOLESALING REAL ESTATE LEGAL
Is Wholesaling Real Estate Legal?

Unlike most real estate investment strategies, wholesaling gives you a chance to make a lot of money

How Investors Find Off Market Properties
How Investors Find Off-Market Properties

Real estate investment markets have never been more active, which is why successful investors know how to

BUILDING ABSENTEE OWNER LEADS
How to Make Winning Investments with an Absentee Owner List

When it comes to generating real estate leads for your business, you have several options. There are

Driving for Dollars done right with BatchLeads!
Driving for dollars done right with BatchLeads

https://batchleads.io/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Driving-for-Dollars-done-right-with-BatchLeads.mp4 Hosted By Landree Morby BatchService Description Transcript Driving for Dollars is a great way to find

Try risk free for 7 days

All-inclusive phone numbers and emails on every plan

Growth

$
119
/mo
Start Free Trial

For the solopreneur growing your business.

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
10k monthly leads
20k monthly exports
BatchRankAI (limited)
3 total users
Nationwide listing & property data
140+ customizable lead filters
Built-in marketing & driving for dollars

RECOMMENDED

Professional

$
349
/mo
Start Free Trial

Take full advantage of the product suite.

Everything in Growth, plus:

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
35k monthly leads
70k monthly exports
BatchRankAI
Click-to-dial
8 total users
Discounted direct mail

Scale

$
749
/mo
Start Free Trial

You’re ready to put some jet fuel in the tank.

Everything in Professional, plus:

All-inclusive phone numbers & emails
Unlimited storage
75k monthly leads
150k monthly exports
26 total users
Maximum discounts on in-app purchases